Territory War Matchmaker

Replies

  • majorjohn
    19 posts Member
    edited May 31
    The matchmaking in the game is significantly flawed, which created an unfair and discouraging game playing experience.
    In yesterday's TW, our guild of sub 380M GP matched with a guild of 450M+ GP. The opposing guild has about 19% higher GP than us and should have never matched with guilds in our current tier.
    ftdb1xtyxzzb.png

    Date of TW: 5/30/2022
    My guild members who joined: 47
    My Guild’s GP: 370M
    98vjsae3k60i.jpg

    Opposing guild members who joined: 48 (calculated by the Starkiller they put in defense)
    Opposing team’s GP: 440M
    6gah5k6izgtp.jpg

  • I would say our last two TWs were mismatches (the first against us, the second in our favour):
    • Date of TW: June 2, 2022
    • Date of TW: Tuesday June 7th, 2022
    • Your Guild’s (Pertharla) GP: 249.6 M GP
    • Opposing team’s (Badly Batched) GP: 322.6 M GP
    • # of my guild members who joined: 48/50
    • # of opposing guild members who joined: Unknown.

    This guild had 1.5M more average GP, not to mention 73 GLs to our 28 at the time; seems a bit off kilter.
    • Date of TW: Tuesday June 7th, 2022
    • Your Guild’s (Pertharla) GP: 250.1 M GP (243.7M Active GP)
    • Opposing team’s (The Order of Madness) GP: 230.6 M GP (201M Active GP)
    • # of my guild members who joined: 48/50
    • # of opposing guild members who joined: 39-45/50

    For this one, the average GP seems more reasonable; ours is 4.99M to their 4.69M, and we have 29 GLs to their 24, but we have 42M more active GP participating). Again, seems a bit off-kilter.

    If you need anything else, DM me.

    Cheers,
    BDLS
  • Oblivionus_SWGoH
    26 posts Member
    edited June 14
    Here are the last two matches we faced.
    The number behind the / are the number of 5-point penalties a guild took for extra attacks (max 2 per squad).
    rGLs are the number of relic GLs the guild has at their full strength (number of players in parentheses).

    #223
    Active GP: 302.6m vs 349.8m - Players: 48 vs 46 - Squads: 37 - rGLs: 86 vs 188 (+102)
    Us - Points: 16.627 - Territories: 3+0 - Squads: 156/51 - Fleets: 0/0 - rGLs: 87 (50)
    Op - Points: 27.993 - Territories: 7+3 - Squads: 296/45 - Fleets: 74/18 - rGLs: 200 (49)
    pmn7fa7psu69.png

    #224
    Active GP: 292.7m vs 333.2m-362.2m - Players: 46 vs 46-50 - Squads: 37 - rGLs: 86 vs 155-168 (+67 to +82)
    Us - Points: 20.209 - Territories: 4+1 - Squads: 156/48 (+17) - Fleets: 74/20 - rGLs: 90 (50)
    Op - Points: 25.040 - Territories: 6+2 - Squads: 256/58 (+4) - Fleets: 74/20 - rGLs: 168 (50)
    eor5fyjszthv.png

    So both times, we faces a guild 2 tiers above ours.
    And with vastly more GLs than us.

    So thank you so very much CG for replacing a broken system with an even more broken system.
    And that you have absolutely no intention whatsoever to improve it.
    Instead you introduce a complex pay-to-win button with Datacrons instead of fixing matchmaking in TWs.

    [CM - Edited for profanity]
    Post edited by EA_Mako on
  • Ahira83
    13 posts Member
    Normally I don't bother to bother people in a forum, but the data (for a whole year) of the TWs confirm our very bad impression of the matchmaking!

    About 85% of all TWs we play against guilds that 1. are one division higher and 2. have partly 800% more Legends.

    This not only frustrates the players immensely and in the long run, but also makes it almost impossible to build up new small guilds.

    If necessary, collected data (screenshots + Data DSR-Bot) can be sent. Nevertheless, a current example as desired.

    GP :: 150.1M vs 180.2M
    Off range :: 4168-5686 vs 4833-11106
    G13 :: 588 vs 1253
    Tier 3 :: 135 vs 249
    Tier 4 :: 79 vs 186
    Tier 5 :: 180 vs 340
    Tier 6 :: 41 vs 85
    Tier 7 :: 88 vs 206
    Tier 8 :: 6 vs 15

    and then...
    Ults :: 1 vs 13

    ...and as I said, no kidding - that's what 85% of our matches look like.

    Guild: Lichtschwertschwinger II


    We really hope that something will change here.

    Best regards and stay healthy!
    Dark Sole


    Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)
  • nottenst
    512 posts Member
    I thought then when guilds are winning a lot in a row they are supposed to be matched higher. Apparently not.

    The results as seen after the match completed.

    Match 1 :: ❌ 14543-17316, 227.9M vs ✅ 17316-14543, 247.1M

    Streak :: 1 ❌ vs 8 ✅
    W-L-D :: 3-5-0, (37.5%) vs 8-0-0, (100.0%)

    They had been 8-0 before and we had won are last one. But they brought 20M more to the TW than we did. Based on what they fielded, they had at least 46 members in, while we had 38.

    I just don't understand what this matchmaking is supposed to be doing.
  • Jakdnels
    661 posts Member
    Is this matchmaking working as intended?

    9vmzomhtvhmd.png

  • Swgohitalia
    25 posts Member
    edited August 1
    4q3nibcqq9ov.jpg
    Today 1st of august 2022
    This is our tw
    We 360 of PG playing in 49-->this mean 352m of PG
    Playing with a 430 milioni of PG guild...
    Are they playing in 20??? Maybe

    This is not the first time...
    vqwoe7t5m8vv.jpg
Sign In or Register to comment.