Mid tier guilds suffering?

Luniz
351 posts Member
I see a lot of 15-20 star geo TB guilds recruiting anywhere from 1-10 members due to people quitting. It's hard for these guilds to merge because there aren't a lot of small guilds to absorb and people are hesitant to break up guilds. My guild is getting less stars than before because even when we do replace people they're generally newer with lower gp. What do you guys think about disbanding guilds, or is there an alternative?

Replies

  • @Luniz it is hard for guilds of all sizes. But yes, Guilds in your range are losing players to larger guilds that need players and are willing to settle for lower GP, especially if they have Geo teams or DR/DM...just the kind that you want to keep. There are several discord servers where you can look for merges..or I can refer you. DM me your discord ID.

  • Btw... the same thing happens whenever new content is released. However the game attrition is not helping.
  • Luniz
    351 posts Member
    yeah its tough out there, deciding to leave or disband a 45 person guild seems like a harsh decision. i'm afraid if i leave, 2 or 3 other of the most active will follow suit and from there i think it would be a death knell. not that i think i'm super important but the most active say 5 members are.
  • G E O = Mid sized guilds worst nightmare 100%
  • G E O = Mid sized guilds worst nightmare 100%

    It just got even worse with handing out get2 for guilds 180m+...even if they loose every tw that is the GP you want your new guild to be at.
    We're at 142m / 15*geo / won 7 out of the last 10 TW'S...we can't grow any further "naturally" anymore. But if we consider to merge towards that Goal we have to throw some good, active people overboard. Sucks.
  • CCyrilS
    3536 posts Member
    Naver666 wrote: »
    G E O = Mid sized guilds worst nightmare 100%

    It just got even worse with handing out get2 for guilds 180m+...even if they loose every tw that is the GP you want your new guild to be at.
    We're at 142m / 15*geo / won 7 out of the last 10 TW'S...we can't grow any further "naturally" anymore. But if we consider to merge towards that Goal we have to throw some good, active people overboard. Sucks.

    Send some of those good active ppl my way.
  • CCyrilS wrote: »
    Naver666 wrote: »
    G E O = Mid sized guilds worst nightmare 100%

    It just got even worse with handing out get2 for guilds 180m+...even if they loose every tw that is the GP you want your new guild to be at.
    We're at 142m / 15*geo / won 7 out of the last 10 TW'S...we can't grow any further "naturally" anymore. But if we consider to merge towards that Goal we have to throw some good, active people overboard. Sucks.

    Send some of those good active ppl my way.

    I'll definitly do so if it goes that way mate :)
  • Just do Hoth TB
  • Luniz
    351 posts Member
    Just do Hoth TB

    Nothing will send a bigger message to guildmates that the guild is dying and they should leave than moving back from Geo to Hoth.
  • Jarvind
    2760 posts Member
    Every time I see these posts, I wonder the same thing: are people actually "quitting" or are the 5-10 people that were doing all the heavy lifting just leaving for guilds of like-minded competitive players?
  • Jarvind wrote: »
    Every time I see these posts, I wonder the same thing: are people actually "quitting" or are the 5-10 people that were doing all the heavy lifting just leaving for guilds of like-minded competitive players?

    I've had both happen. But it's obvious when people quit, if you have them on your friends list and can see they haven't logged in for weeks or months.
  • Support a slingshot mechanic. Older members will leave and be replaced by new members. However, new recruits will typically be below guild average and unable to develop.
  • Nauros
    2910 posts Member
    Mid-tier guilds are set to fail now. Some people leave for better TB results and the replacements are nowhere near their GP, if there are any replacements at all. Whoever stays gets punished for their loyalty by losing in fleet arena and GAC.
    Revive the stores, the game needs it.
  • Luniz wrote: »
    Just do Hoth TB

    Nothing will send a bigger message to guildmates that the guild is dying and they should leave than moving back from Geo to Hoth.

    We alternate for the time being. We're hoping for 16* this time (got 14* last time, but are changing strategy). The issue is that you for that you get around 4500 guild event tokens or something. You get a lot more for 40+ stars in ds hoth tb. And for a guild that has a lot of people (including me) still to finish malak and/or wampa, that currency is important.
  • frackme_21 wrote: »
    Luniz wrote: »
    Just do Hoth TB

    Nothing will send a bigger message to guildmates that the guild is dying and they should leave than moving back from Geo to Hoth.

    We alternate for the time being. We're hoping for 16* this time (got 14* last time, but are changing strategy). The issue is that you for that you get around 4500 guild event tokens or something. You get a lot more for 40+ stars in ds hoth tb. And for a guild that has a lot of people (including me) still to finish malak and/or wampa, that currency is important.

    Probably shouldnt give up 100% of your negotiator currency for 15% faster wampa.
  • TVF
    17351 posts Member
    frackme_21 wrote: »
    Luniz wrote: »
    Just do Hoth TB

    Nothing will send a bigger message to guildmates that the guild is dying and they should leave than moving back from Geo to Hoth.

    We alternate for the time being. We're hoping for 16* this time (got 14* last time, but are changing strategy). The issue is that you for that you get around 4500 guild event tokens or something. You get a lot more for 40+ stars in ds hoth tb. And for a guild that has a lot of people (including me) still to finish malak and/or wampa, that currency is important.

    Probably shouldnt give up 100% of your negotiator currency for 15% faster wampa.

    I like how you cherry picked the wampa part.
    TVF's guild is recruiting. Say hi in our Discord! https://discord.gg/AmStGTH
  • No_Try
    3812 posts Member
    frackme_21 wrote: »
    Luniz wrote: »
    Just do Hoth TB

    Nothing will send a bigger message to guildmates that the guild is dying and they should leave than moving back from Geo to Hoth.

    We alternate for the time being. We're hoping for 16* this time (got 14* last time, but are changing strategy). The issue is that you for that you get around 4500 guild event tokens or something. You get a lot more for 40+ stars in ds hoth tb. And for a guild that has a lot of people (including me) still to finish malak and/or wampa, that currency is important.

    Probably shouldnt give up 100% of your negotiator currency for 15% faster wampa.

    Wampa lives matter.
    7qs0i5a9cytv.png
Sign In or Register to comment.