Star Wars Galaxy of Heroes Forums› Feedback Home› Characters

New player? Check out the new player index

rogue one

Darthcole
Darthcole
84 posts Member
how come rogue one team members don't have rogue one titles?

Replies

  • Gothamjediknight
    Gothamjediknight
    45 posts Member
    Options
    Well, because Rogue One isn't a faction. A better question would be why don't Vet Han and Chewie have Resistance tags.
  • EmeraldZx
    EmeraldZx
    176 posts Member
    Options
    Gothamjediknight wrote: »
    Well, because Rogue One isn't a faction. A better question would be why don't Vet Han and Chewie have Resistance tags.

    Because Chewie would destroy raids alongside BB8 under Finn
  • EmeraldZx
    EmeraldZx
    176 posts Member
    Options
    Darthcole wrote: »
    how come rogue one team members don't have rogue one titles?

    I agree they should have tags because they ARE a faction. Otherwise they wouldn't have a combat mission to themselves in TB.
  • Gothamjediknight
    Gothamjediknight
    45 posts Member
    Options
    EmeraldZx wrote: »
    Darthcole wrote: »
    how come rogue one team members don't have rogue one titles?

    I agree they should have tags because they ARE a faction. Otherwise they wouldn't have a combat mission to themselves in TB.
    EmeraldZx wrote: »
    Gothamjediknight wrote: »
    Well, because Rogue One isn't a faction. A better question would be why don't Vet Han and Chewie have Resistance tags.

    Because Chewie would destroy raids alongside BB8 under Finn


    So, according to you, resistance members being tagged as resistance and rebels being tagged as rebels is a problem?
  • clarkdiesel
    clarkdiesel
    306 posts Member
    Options
    Gothamjediknight wrote: »
    Well, because Rogue One isn't a faction. A better question would be why don't Vet Han and Chewie have Resistance tags.

    Definition of faction is a small, organized, dissenting group within a larger group, especially in politics. Can be argued that rogue one is the very definition of faction, moreso than the others.

    Irregardless, doesn’t have to be factions. It’s a filter for characters that’s already set up by the devs in TB when we are required to have the rogue one toons. Crew member or healer are not a faction. Just asking to move the rogue one filter over to character screen.
  • STRYKER667
    STRYKER667
    153 posts Member
    Options
    Gothamjediknight wrote: »
    EmeraldZx wrote: »
    Darthcole wrote: »
    how come rogue one team members don't have rogue one titles?

    I agree they should have tags because they ARE a faction. Otherwise they wouldn't have a combat mission to themselves in TB.
    EmeraldZx wrote: »
    Gothamjediknight wrote: »
    Well, because Rogue One isn't a faction. A better question would be why don't Vet Han and Chewie have Resistance tags.

    Because Chewie would destroy raids alongside BB8 under Finn


    So, according to you, resistance members being tagged as resistance and rebels being tagged as rebels is a problem?

    Except that Rogue one toons are tagged as Rebels. Just not as R1. And The vets are not tagged as Resistance and I agree they should be.
  • Kronen
    Kronen
    306 posts Member
    Options
    Because rogue one was a title for the film not the name of the faction. If we did that all the characters from force awakens would have a force awakens lable including the first order.
  • Wolfkid
    Wolfkid
    51 posts Member
    Options
    Or this
    Rogue One: rebels
    Rogue One: empire

    And same with tfa
  • clarkdiesel
    clarkdiesel
    306 posts Member
    Options
    Kronen wrote: »
    Because rogue one was a title for the film not the name of the faction. If we did that all the characters from force awakens would have a force awakens lable including the first order.

    No, it was the name of the group on Scariff. Before they took off in the stolen shuttle, they were asked their call sign. Jyn told Bodhi to say something and he said, “rogue....rogue one.” Even Admiral Raddus called them rogue one when he received the Death Star plans.

  • clarkdiesel
    clarkdiesel
    306 posts Member
    Options
    Don’t think the new Empire characters that were introduced in the Rogue One movie need “rogue one” filter. There’s only 3 and they were a part of the empire that just happened to be attacked by the Rogue One Rebels.
  • SaviourOfTheSith
    SaviourOfTheSith
    48 posts Member
    Options
    Agree, rogue rebels should have tag
  • Krayden_Phogg
    Krayden_Phogg
    1685 posts Member
    Options
    clarkdiesel wrote: »
    Kronen wrote: »
    Because rogue one was a title for the film not the name of the faction. If we did that all the characters from force awakens would have a force awakens lable including the first order.

    No, it was the name of the group on Scariff. Before they took off in the stolen shuttle, they were asked their call sign. Jyn told Bodhi to say something and he said, “rogue....rogue one.” Even Admiral Raddus called them rogue one when he received the Death Star plans.
    Correct. +1
  • Shaheen
    Shaheen
    88 posts Member
    Options
    +1 for spelling 'rogue one' right
  • adfcta
    adfcta
    27 posts Member
    Options
    It seems like if imperial troopers ha e a unique tag, other than "Empire," then it shouldn't be much of a stretch to think that the rogue one group could have its own tag.

    Not that it makes much difference to me, but it's a fair question.
  • Teague
    Teague
    939 posts Member
    Options
    clarkdiesel wrote: »
    Kronen wrote: »
    Because rogue one was a title for the film not the name of the faction. If we did that all the characters from force awakens would have a force awakens lable including the first order.

    No, it was the name of the group on Scariff. Before they took off in the stolen shuttle, they were asked their call sign. Jyn told Bodhi to say something and he said, “rogue....rogue one.” Even Admiral Raddus called them rogue one when he received the Death Star plans.

    Bistan didn't go with them, yet is considered R1. He came with Raddus as air support reinforcements. If he's R1, do should Leia. She was there for the battle as well.
  • Kyno
    Kyno
    32087 posts Moderator
    Options
    Moved to correct sub forum.

  • clarkdiesel
    clarkdiesel
    306 posts Member
    Options
    Teague wrote: »
    clarkdiesel wrote: »
    Kronen wrote: »
    Because rogue one was a title for the film not the name of the faction. If we did that all the characters from force awakens would have a force awakens lable including the first order.

    No, it was the name of the group on Scariff. Before they took off in the stolen shuttle, they were asked their call sign. Jyn told Bodhi to say something and he said, “rogue....rogue one.” Even Admiral Raddus called them rogue one when he received the Death Star plans.

    Bistan didn't go with them, yet is considered R1. He came with Raddus as air support reinforcements. If he's R1, do should Leia. She was there for the battle as well.

    But Bistan fought on Scariff. Leia did not. Rogue one was on Scariff. Bistan and the rest of blue squadron linked up with Rogue One.

    Basically, you could get super technical about everything like trying to include Leia with Rogue One because she was near Scariff but not on Scariff. Vader could be a Rebel because he helped Luke overthrow the Emperor. Lando could be dark side because he betrayed Han. All the Ewoks could be Rebels and so on. See where I’m going? I don’t think anyone mistakes Leia for Rogue One. The whole point is having a separate filter, of which is already in place for TB, of rebel toons specifically associated with Rogue One. There are 9 of them, 8 if you want to be super technical and remove Bistan because he wasn’t on the shuttle to Scariff.

Reply to this topic
Sign In or Register to comment.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Log In Create Account