Kick players from Hoth if they are still at 0 points in the last wave.

VesperVDH
5 posts Member
edited February 2019
I know, people are busy with work, studies, it can happen. But it is a source of great irritation that some players join Hoth or TW but do nothing. So instead of kicking them from the Guild, the leader should have the power to remove certain players from the list as a reminder that if you don't contribute, you won't benefit from the spoils ;)

Replies

  • crzydroid
    5923 posts Moderator
    You can already kick them from the guild if you want before it ends. They won't get rewards.
  • crzydroid wrote: »
    You can already kick them from the guild if you want before it ends. They won't get rewards.

    I think he wants to solely kick them from the event rewards list, not the guild as a whole. As in he wants their 600, but doesn't want them to not participate. As in the OP should just boot them and recruit rather than continue to allow poor behavior.
  • Kyno
    31539 posts Moderator
    Vertigo wrote: »
    crzydroid wrote: »
    You can already kick them from the guild if you want before it ends. They won't get rewards.

    I think he wants to solely kick them from the event rewards list, not the guild as a whole. As in he wants their 600, but doesn't want them to not participate. As in the OP should just boot them and recruit rather than continue to allow poor behavior.

    If he wants the guild to benefit from them being in guild, then they should benefit from being a part of the guild event. It's pretty simple.
  • @Kyno, the only issue with your claim is that you're not benefitting in that particular guild event. There's no # threshold for TB, like there is for TW. Someone joining and posting a 0 GP by the end of Day 6 has quite literally set the guild back. You're possibly/actually earning less rewards by having them be part of it yet they still claim a reward.

    It takes ten seconds go in each day and just hit "Deploy" in a fleet and character zone. About as much time as simming your daily challenges.
  • VesperVDH wrote: »
    I know, people are busy with work, studies, it can happen. But it is a source of great irritation that some players join Hoth or TW but do nothing. So instead of kicking them from the Guild, the leader should have the power to remove certain players from the list as a reminder that if you don't contribute, you won't benefit from the spoils ;)

    Doesn’t booting them from the guild remind them that they won’t benefit from the spoils?

    I say just kick them altogether. What’s the point of having a deadbeat in the guild?
  • Kyno
    31539 posts Moderator
    Vendi1983 wrote: »
    Kyno, the only issue with your claim is that you're not benefitting in that particular guild event. There's no # threshold for TB, like there is for TW. Someone joining and posting a 0 GP by the end of Day 6 has quite literally set the guild back. You're possibly/actually earning less rewards by having them be part of it yet they still claim a reward.

    It takes ten seconds go in each day and just hit "Deploy" in a fleet and character zone. About as much time as simming your daily challenges.

    If you dont want them in your guild because there is no benefit then kick them out of the guild for doing nothing.

    The post I was replying to was suggesting that they didnt want to kick them out of the guild because they still had a benefit for the guild, but to remove them from the event so they dont get rewards.

    A - they do nothing in an event and do nothing (or not the minimums) for the guild = kick them out of the guild
    B - they dont hit the event, but are still active doing stuff (ex. -600,...)for the guild - odd, but hey they are helping. Kick them out of the guild of you dont like it, but no you will not have an option to just remove the rewards that are stated to be equal for everyone in the guild.

    In B you are getting a benefit, just not the one you are looking for. They could be benefitting you more sure, but they did contribute to the guild, and it is a guild event.
  • There are options between "let them do nothing" and "kick them".

    Filter TW/TB rewards that if you're eligible to participate (TB)/join (TW) and post a 0 GP/0 banner score by the end you're left with 0 rewards.

    TB/TW aren't like HAAT and HPit for most guilds. They require coordination and a ton of investment by everyone participating to maximize the identical rewards for all.
  • Vendi1983 wrote: »
    There are options between "let them do nothing" and "kick them".

    Filter TW/TB rewards that if you're eligible to participate (TB)/join (TW) and post a 0 GP/0 banner score by the end you're left with 0 rewards.

    TB/TW aren't like HAAT and HPit for most guilds. They require coordination and a ton of investment by everyone participating to maximize the identical rewards for all.

    If they're not participating in the TW/TB then what do you still need them for? I'm sure you can complete Hpit and HAAT. Are they helping significantly in the Sith raid?

    99% of the time the people that are putting up 0 point in Territory Battles aren't helping the guild out in any other way other than maybe getting their 600 tickets a day. Either message them individually to warn them that if they do nothing they will be booted or just boot them.

    People are just curious why you need to keep them around if they're literally not helping the guild. You have the ability to message them, if they don't respond they're clearly not that active, just boot them. You can find someone to replace them that will participate, there are tons of people that play this game and are looking for guilds very often.
  • Kyno
    31539 posts Moderator
    Vendi1983 wrote: »
    There are options between "let them do nothing" and "kick them".

    Filter TW/TB rewards that if you're eligible to participate (TB)/join (TW) and post a 0 GP/0 banner score by the end you're left with 0 rewards.

    TB/TW aren't like HAAT and HPit for most guilds. They require coordination and a ton of investment by everyone participating to maximize the identical rewards for all.

    Please see above.

    If they help keep them and they get the same rewards as every other guild member, because it's a guild event and they are in your guild.

    If they dont help, then why do you want them there?

    Events are not like raids, but if the player is worth being in a guild for any reason they should get guild rewards.
  • Kyno wrote: »
    Vendi1983 wrote: »
    There are options between "let them do nothing" and "kick them".

    Filter TW/TB rewards that if you're eligible to participate (TB)/join (TW) and post a 0 GP/0 banner score by the end you're left with 0 rewards.

    TB/TW aren't like HAAT and HPit for most guilds. They require coordination and a ton of investment by everyone participating to maximize the identical rewards for all.

    Please see above.

    If they help keep them and they get the same rewards as every other guild member, because it's a guild event and they are in your guild.

    If they dont help, then why do you want them there?

    Events are not like raids, but if the player is worth being in a guild for any reason they should get guild rewards.

    0 Banners in TW gives 0 rewards, but 0 Territory Points in TB gives rewards it makes no sense
  • If people score 0 banners in a TW they do not get the rewards. TB should be the same.
Sign In or Register to comment.