How many guilds have broken up due to raids rewards or lost a large number of members?

Baldo

jayskywalker

Still going strong

At least 1..

medetec

We are a friendly, more relaxed guild so no one has left. Everyone agrees the reward system is awful though, including the top players.

Mofojokers1992

Still going strong

medetec wrote: »

We are a friendly, more relaxed guild so no one has left. Everyone agrees the reward system is awful though, including the top players.

This we have all come to the forums voting to hope that CG will eventually listen. Need are lower guys to keep up if we are to push futher up to herioc.

EM650

Close to it

We have definitely lost people because of it. Also, I have completed a half dozen T6 raids and STILL do not have one of those unobtainable pieces of gear that we can supposedly get through guild raids.

On top of that I know many people who have been able to obtain 8 or more furnaces 8n shipments. I got 2 initially which helped me max my Rey, but I have not seen any in a few weeks now. Others in my guild have not yet received their first furnace yet. This system is SERIOUSLY flawed. If we are paying nearly $20 per furnace, then they should just be a permanent fixture in the shipments like the Sim tickets rather than leaving it to crappie RNG.

Baldo

Broken up

EM650 wrote: »

We have definitely lost people because of it. Also, I have completed a half dozen T6 raids and STILL do not have one of those unobtainable pieces of gear that we can supposedly get through guild raids.

On top of that I know many people who have been able to obtain 8 or more furnaces 8n shipments. I got 2 initially which helped me max my Rey, but I have not seen any in a few weeks now. Others in my guild have not yet received their first furnace yet. This system is SERIOUSLY flawed. If we are paying nearly $20 per furnace, then they should just be a permanent fixture in the shipments like the Sim tickets rather than leaving it to crappie RNG.

Sucks.

Tlon

Still going strong

We have a great guild filled with casual players, but like others have said we all think the reward system is garbage, and it is the only thing that creates a sense of unfairness and tension in the Guild.

Also like others have said, even the people who consistently finish at the top and who benefit the most from the current system feel that it needs to be changed. It is a really terrible system.

dvl009

kicked 1 and 2 others left. there are a few 'naughty' members who sneaked in more guild activity points than agreed maxium number in the last minutes