Our guild just cleared the revamped raid in 1 hour 45 minutes with 31 players, and our guild is a global guild. No longer having to coordinate 100% dmg all at once made this actually easier since we could use more of our roster instead of just 4 teams each. Thank you CG for this rework!
Our guild (225M) got through P1 for the first time. Now at least we can see actual progress in the raid. I don't think we have enough squads to get through it all, but we'll see.
My guilds first run. This was bat dump crazy, we took only 30 min in total. Given that it can comfortably and fast completed now, I think these changes stroke a good note for guilds that can easily do it before/after.
My guilds first run. This was bat dump crazy, we took only 30 min in total. Given that it can comfortably and fast completed now, I think these changes stroke a good note for guilds that can easily do it before/after.
Entirely different experience with our run so far. We started today so it is a bit early to judge, but ater almost 4 hours, it seems my prediction were correct. Teams intended for p3 are already getting used in p2, so it will be a small miracle if we get to p4. Before, we completed it even with some mistakes or crashes...
My guilds first run. This was bat dump crazy, we took only 30 min in total. Given that it can comfortably and fast completed now, I think these changes stroke a good note for guilds that can easily do it before/after.
Entirely different experience with our run so far. We started today so it is a bit early to judge, but ater almost 4 hours, it seems my prediction were correct. Teams intended for p3 are already getting used in p2, so it will be a small miracle if we get to p4. Before, we completed it even with some mistakes or crashes...
I dunno, we are leagues above the needs. Only 28 people managed to get a hit in. In the case of coming short, your guild shouldn't play it ffa and allow vader-ers do p1 etc. Optimal team lists should be made up shortly.
I dunno, we are leagues above the needs. Only 28 people managed to get a hit in. In the case of coming short, your guild shouldn't play it ffa and allow vader-ers do p1 etc. Optimal team lists should be made up shortly.
We ended up with about 60% left in P2. So, our guild has quite some distance to go. Seeing optimal team lists for phases will at least give us some specific goals.
My guilds first run. This was bat dump crazy, we took only 30 min in total. Given that it can comfortably and fast completed now, I think these changes stroke a good note for guilds that can easily do it before/after.
Entirely different experience with our run so far. We started today so it is a bit early to judge, but ater almost 4 hours, it seems my prediction were correct. Teams intended for p3 are already getting used in p2, so it will be a small miracle if we get to p4. Before, we completed it even with some mistakes or crashes...
I’d guess my guild is not as overpowered for the raid as MaruMaru, still cleaned it out pretty easily though.
We restricted P1 to Padme for the first 80% (about 4 hours), then finished off with Rey/Vader and some smaller teams.
Everyone was asked to spend only 1 food team in P2 and P3 to take maximum advantage of topple and all were asked to keep back usual P4 teams.
Due to sleep schedules etc I think it took almost 12 hours before we reached P4. That phase took like 1-2 hours despite a lot of the guild being sound asleep at that time.
We had a lot of good teams left unused.
Previously we’ve had no issues getting to P4, but have had a few runs where we had to Zerg more of P4 than is fun. No such issues with new mechanics.
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Nothing trash about it.
So you mean to tell me that a proper solution is to dilute the amount of relic mats for everyone to make it “fair” rather than CG actually leveling the rewards out? I mean if I was someone with lots of R5 toons and was told to sit out, or got less R8 mats due to bad RNG placement in the standings I’d be miffed regardless
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Nothing trash about it.
So you mean to tell me that a proper solution is to dilute the amount of relic mats for everyone to make it “fair” rather than CG actually leveling the rewards out? I mean if I was someone with lots of R5 toons and was told to sit out, or got less R8 mats due to bad RNG placement in the standings I’d be miffed regardless
Never said it was proper. But I am one of those guys who has a lot of r5+ and have no issues with the concept of getting a little less in return for 49 others who can benefit. But then again that's the entire point of being in a "guild". A guild that only has 15 guys getting the best isn't a very good guild imo. But CG can definitely help in this area with the rewards structure no doubt.
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Nothing trash about it.
Sitting out a raid is trash.
I'm actually pretty sure he was just talking about splitting into two actual guilds each week to do the raid, since he was upset because he thought the changes would make it impossible to complete with 25.
Yeah same experience here as well. About 30 guys posted damage quicker than we all expected. It was nice to be able to use some teams I couldn't before the changes were made and overall definitely a win win for almost everyone. I don't see CG winning here(besides the important win ⁰from us) and that's odd. Let's hope no changes are made to bump up the difficulty.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Nothing trash about it.
Sitting out a raid is trash.
I'm actually pretty sure he was just talking about splitting into two actual guilds each week to do the raid, since he was upset because he thought the changes would make it impossible to complete with 25.
I thought it would be impossible or him?
Because if you’re referring to me I never said that. I said it would require a bigger gear dump due to needing more teams as it would make the amount of teams needed increase.
Well that was fun - took less than 25 mins! Dare I say it it's almost too easy now?
I’m gonna agree with this, knowing I’m using a quote of “duh a challenge I can do” I’m selfish so I want a raid challenging enough that we can complete but hard enough others can’t(participation trophy) and at first run it was way to fast, way to easy and we only used 20 guild members.
Well that was fun - took less than 25 mins! Dare I say it it's almost too easy now?
I’m gonna agree with this, knowing I’m using a quote of “duh a challenge I can do” I’m selfish so I want a raid challenging enough that we can complete but hard enough others can’t(participation trophy) and at first run it was way to fast, way to easy and we only used 20 guild members.
Well that was fun - took less than 25 mins! Dare I say it it's almost too easy now?
I’m gonna agree with this, knowing I’m using a quote of “duh a challenge I can do” I’m selfish so I want a raid challenging enough that we can complete but hard enough others can’t(participation trophy) and at first run it was way to fast, way to easy and we only used 20 guild members.
There are plenty of guilds that still can't do this.
Well they are just great. I thought the guy above me was bad but at least you got carbantis... I just got 3 lots of 10 garbage... didn't know it was even possible to get all 10's.
Replies
No roster refreshes
Entirely different experience with our run so far. We started today so it is a bit early to judge, but ater almost 4 hours, it seems my prediction were correct. Teams intended for p3 are already getting used in p2, so it will be a small miracle if we get to p4. Before, we completed it even with some mistakes or crashes...
I dunno, we are leagues above the needs. Only 28 people managed to get a hit in. In the case of coming short, your guild shouldn't play it ffa and allow vader-ers do p1 etc. Optimal team lists should be made up shortly.
I’d guess my guild is not as overpowered for the raid as MaruMaru, still cleaned it out pretty easily though.
We restricted P1 to Padme for the first 80% (about 4 hours), then finished off with Rey/Vader and some smaller teams.
Everyone was asked to spend only 1 food team in P2 and P3 to take maximum advantage of topple and all were asked to keep back usual P4 teams.
Due to sleep schedules etc I think it took almost 12 hours before we reached P4. That phase took like 1-2 hours despite a lot of the guild being sound asleep at that time.
We had a lot of good teams left unused.
Previously we’ve had no issues getting to P4, but have had a few runs where we had to Zerg more of P4 than is fun. No such issues with new mechanics.
Seemed so much easier in terms of coordination stress.
Consider me a convert. Well done CG.
Well the rewards are still garbage in terms of gear pool and the discrepancy in r8 mats
yeah but since the raid is easier now, you can split the guild into two and get equal number of r8 mats across the guild
You mean half hits and the other half sits out every other raid? If so, that’s trash lol
Nothing trash about it.
So you mean to tell me that a proper solution is to dilute the amount of relic mats for everyone to make it “fair” rather than CG actually leveling the rewards out? I mean if I was someone with lots of R5 toons and was told to sit out, or got less R8 mats due to bad RNG placement in the standings I’d be miffed regardless
Never said it was proper. But I am one of those guys who has a lot of r5+ and have no issues with the concept of getting a little less in return for 49 others who can benefit. But then again that's the entire point of being in a "guild". A guild that only has 15 guys getting the best isn't a very good guild imo. But CG can definitely help in this area with the rewards structure no doubt.
Sitting out a raid is trash.
I'm actually pretty sure he was just talking about splitting into two actual guilds each week to do the raid, since he was upset because he thought the changes would make it impossible to complete with 25.
I thought it would be impossible or him?
Because if you’re referring to me I never said that. I said it would require a bigger gear dump due to needing more teams as it would make the amount of teams needed increase.
I’m gonna agree with this, knowing I’m using a quote of “duh a challenge I can do” I’m selfish so I want a raid challenging enough that we can complete but hard enough others can’t(participation trophy) and at first run it was way to fast, way to easy and we only used 20 guild members.
Careful what you wish for.
DISCLAIMER: Post is subject to change.
There are plenty of guilds that still can't do this.
@CG_Doja_Fett @CG_SBCrumb why does every single reward you guys hand out include junk tank raid gear???? Give me a break
Well they are just great. I thought the guy above me was bad but at least you got carbantis... I just got 3 lots of 10 garbage... didn't know it was even possible to get all 10's.