There should be a rule about removing members from a guild during territory wars.
I don't know what I did but I just got kicked out during territory wars. Pitiful!!!
I want restitution!!!
Tell me if I'm wrong?
You had only been in the guild a few hours so it’s not like you’re being robbed of three days effort. But I agree it would suck for officers to deprive people of rewards by booting them just for kicks.
And even scarier it's that they can kick you minutes before it starts and now you don't have time to find another guild and you can miss out on the rewards this was too. I think something needs to be done for those situations considering how important TB rewards can be
Well that really depends. If you were in my guild for 4 days of TB and you hadn’t made any contribution to it I’d kick you as well. I’m not saying that’s what you’ve done, I’m just saying that’s one reason for a fair boot during a TB.
Well that really depends. If you were in my guild for 4 days of TB and you hadn’t made any contribution to it I’d kick you as well. I’m not saying that’s what you’ve done, I’m just saying that’s one reason for a fair boot during a TB.
I guess you're right, although the guy said he doesn't know why he was kicked which isn't something someone who's not participating would say. Unless he's a liar, but given the info he's shared I'm drawing a conclusion for that particular situation
You had only been in the guild a few hours so it’s not like you’re being robbed of three days effort. But I agree it would suck for officers to deprive people of rewards by booting them just for kicks.
I did contribute 3 days worth of TB and they kicked me out. I should file that under abuse of power!!!
I did contribute I am not joking
Can someone tell me how I can message CG for a complaint?
What I want to know is how you have 4 posts in this thread but it says you have only posted 3 times. Maybe because the original post is the thread starter? 🤔
I would try sending the guikd leader a message asking what the deal is. If you had him allied or know his ally code you can do that in game. Obviously its too late for the rewards but you may get some closure from that.
For all we know it may have been an accident. They may have been trying to boot the one above or below you for non participation.
We (Celtic Rage) only kick people out for being inactive 7 days or not joining 2 consecutive TW's. Some people let their heads get too big when they get even a spec of power. The OP makes me appreciate being in a good guild.
Having been a leader or officer in every guild I've been in, and many of them having been top guilds, all I can say is that booting someone during an event is pretty much only done when that member has screwed up big time.
You boot someone mid TB or TW and you can't get any contributions from them.
You also can't bring in a good member because no one wants to leave a guild mid event and give up rewards to join another.
So basically either the OP is leaving out relevant information, or the guild he was in is run by the most incompetent people playing the game.
It is possible that the guild had a legitimate reason for kicking OP and also that OP doesn't know what it is. Those things can be true at the same time.
I've removed a few, very very rarely during the event however. On top of the issues brought up another possibility is the leader found a much better player who wanted in immediately. A pretty crap call, but possible.
We (Celtic Rage) only kick people out for being inactive 7 days or not joining 2 consecutive TW's. Some people let their heads get too big when they get even a spec of power. The OP makes me appreciate being in a good guild.
I would disagree that booting for only those reasons is good for the guild. What is good depends on the goals. For example, if the guild is trying to get hstr for the first time, requiring participation in that is completely fine. Although now that many guilds have it on farm, that req is becoming far less common.
With the new tb, participation in that is mandatory in many guilds. Also a req to get 600 tickets a day is also a common rule.
Booting for any of these rules isn't a power trip as long as the rules are clearly stated and people are given warnings first.
But I agree that booting without warning is usually bad form.
Replies
I guess you're right, although the guy said he doesn't know why he was kicked which isn't something someone who's not participating would say. Unless he's a liar, but given the info he's shared I'm drawing a conclusion for that particular situation
Unless McGgee101 is the new Mol Eliza and this is a different one...
I did contribute 3 days worth of TB and they kicked me out. I should file that under abuse of power!!!
I did contribute I am not joking
Can someone tell me how I can message CG for a complaint?
@Kyno do you have any thoughts on this?
You got detention
Yes I am in Nest of Gundarks now but just this morning at 1am I got kicked out of my previous guild Sonoma grey Knights
Denny Crane
Did you fail to join a Discord/Line group?
I would try sending the guikd leader a message asking what the deal is. If you had him allied or know his ally code you can do that in game. Obviously its too late for the rewards but you may get some closure from that.
For all we know it may have been an accident. They may have been trying to boot the one above or below you for non participation.
Either that or just find a new guild and mive on.
"Accidentally".... sure
You boot someone mid TB or TW and you can't get any contributions from them.
You also can't bring in a good member because no one wants to leave a guild mid event and give up rewards to join another.
So basically either the OP is leaving out relevant information, or the guild he was in is run by the most incompetent people playing the game.
I would disagree that booting for only those reasons is good for the guild. What is good depends on the goals. For example, if the guild is trying to get hstr for the first time, requiring participation in that is completely fine. Although now that many guilds have it on farm, that req is becoming far less common.
With the new tb, participation in that is mandatory in many guilds. Also a req to get 600 tickets a day is also a common rule.
Booting for any of these rules isn't a power trip as long as the rules are clearly stated and people are given warnings first.
But I agree that booting without warning is usually bad form.