my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Any feedback on the existing imbalance between the two GLs? Kylo was already Reys equal in PVP and can solo the raid. She maxes out at around 18M in P4 of HSTR.
Now people like me who went for Rey have a character who is less capable in PVE, and he's just as good as her in PVP. This buff was completely unnecessary and like taking a sledgehammer to fix a minor GAS counter. JKR still beats Rey...should we expect a buff for that?
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Still doesn’t change that he is doing that. Any reports on getting it fixed?
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Still doesn’t change that he is doing that. Any reports on getting it fixed?
Fixed implies something is broken. The first time he does it, if Rey is running GK (which is the common team), everyone gets crit immunity. Unless you have some other way to dispel it, you either need to spend an ultimate turn clearing buffs, or just AOE without crits.
While its true that kylo can solo the raid, I don't think that's as consequential. If you have unlocked a GL, chances are you are able to solo the sith raid with your roster anyway, or that it's no longer a challenge for your guild. It doesn't really matter that much that he can solo it.
Unless they change HSTR reward payouts, it's definitely consequential. There's a major difference between rank 1-10 and rank 11 rewards. Getting a solo with multiple teams is incredibly unlikely (you'd have to get into each phase before anyone posts any damage to that phase, and then solo with that team fast enough to get into the next phase in the same situation). If your guild has 10 SLKRs soloing, then you're locked out of top 10 rewards without him.
While its true that kylo can solo the raid, I don't think that's as consequential. If you have unlocked a GL, chances are you are able to solo the sith raid with your roster anyway, or that it's no longer a challenge for your guild. It doesn't really matter that much that he can solo it.
Unless they change HSTR reward payouts, it's definitely consequential. There's a major difference between rank 1-10 and rank 11 rewards. Getting a solo with multiple teams is incredibly unlikely (you'd have to get into each phase before anyone posts any damage to that phase, and then solo with that team fast enough to get into the next phase in the same situation). If your guild has 10 SLKRs soloing, then you're locked out of top 10 rewards without him.
This is a huge issue. Because I chose Rey over Kylo, I will soon be locked out of useful rewards from the STR. That's kind of a problem, since that's the biggest source of the g12+ gear.
lol it’ll make all the original po’d people happy. just makes it unbalanced. kylo can go on his ultimate over and over again. rey can’t. maybe make kylos ultimate only 100% as well otherwise it’s a bit OP, or edit Rey’s kit to make them even.
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Still doesn’t change that he is doing that. Any reports on getting it fixed?
I didn't say it did. just wanted to make sure they knew what was going on according to what they were saying.
They are aware, and there are discussions. Thats all i got to share right now.
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Still doesn’t change that he is doing that. Any reports on getting it fixed?
Fixed implies something is broken. The first time he does it, if Rey is running GK (which is the common team), everyone gets crit immunity. Unless you have some other way to dispel it, you either need to spend an ultimate turn clearing buffs, or just AOE without crits.
Not in a game. In a game it could mean that it is an unexpected interaction. But that’s also only one comp. There are others where this happens. There are videos on it.
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Still doesn’t change that he is doing that. Any reports on getting it fixed?
Ye,never, a crit is a crit is not a bug the the ability is as intended...
i think the point is that after the buff, with this existing mechanic, he’s extremely cheap. it was somewhat even before with the ultimate and not always a guaranteed win. with this new buff it takes him to an entirely different level. he is 100% the best character in the game.
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
You can’t tell me with a straight face that Ultimate Infinite Loop Kylo along with hit hard enough to circumvent procting damage immunity on Rey’s teammates, one of the most valuable pieces of her kit, is balanced with Rey.
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
You can’t tell me with a straight face that Ultimate Infinite Loop Kylo along with hit hard enough to circumvent procting damage immunity on Rey’s teammates, one of the most valuable pieces of her kit, is balanced with Rey.
Please, honestly.
I can tell you I will need you to reword that because I have no clue what you are saying. From what I can gather you are trying to extrapolate something from what I said in reply to another post, to make some point that I was not trying to discuss.....
I have a pretty well modded Ult GL Rey. I have had played against a few Ult SLKR. The fact that Kylo does not take damage while in his ultimate stance is what kills GL Rey. She can get her ultimate even after Kylo starts his and Rey's ultimate will proc before Kylo is out of his stance. Now if you decide to not use the ultimate til later than you lose to Kylo's ultimate ripping everyone apart. If you were able to kill allies quicker this wouldn't be a problem but since the allies now have crit immunity (especially with one tank who gives advantage to a random ally for two turns as a unique) they take longer to kill and SLKR has more time to build up the ultimate that ends up going one right after the other do to the added time to kill.
I had rey do three whirlwinds on SLKR and he gains more health back than the whirlwind does damage on SLKR.
well for me rey hasnt improved my wave count at all in p1-3
she cant be used in gr missions
she cant be used in jedi missions
she cant be used in special missions
one of the important characters is already used for rjt (hero finn) who guarantees 16/16 with rtj
so unless something magical happens in p4 i dont see her value in geo tb so far
overall hsr top10 is still the most important gearincome and thats kylos spot
my only concern is that when Rey is in ultimate stance and kylo does his aoe it counts as critical hits even though they do 1 damage only. @CG_SBCrumb is that supposed to happen? he can spam ultimate and aoe on loop. seems weird that 1 damage counts as critical hits
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Still doesn’t change that he is doing that. Any reports on getting it fixed?
Ye,never, a crit is a crit is not a bug the the ability is as intended...
Well what should be a bug is the infinite loop. If you want it around, then go for it. I don’t care as it doesn’t affect me rn, so I couldn’t care less. Do what you want.
Apparently not enough people were working on getting SLKR. This is just to sweeten the pot a bit more.
Just that it won't work on people who still have some common sense. A big whale in my arena has just quit the game for good. This was the final straw for many people. But CG should not only care about the whales but rather think about the larger group of "average" p(l)ayers. Theory crafting and finding better solutions than a boring mirror match are what makes the game fun. If there's no more fun, why get hyped for the next big thing?
Apparently not enough people were working on getting SLKR. This is just to sweeten the pot a bit more.
Just that it won't work on people who still have some common sense. A big whale in my arena has just quit the game for good. This was the final straw for many people. But CG should not only care about the whales but rather think about the larger group of "average" p(l)ayers. Theory crafting and finding better solutions than a boring mirror match are what makes the game fun. If there's no more fun, why get hyped for the next big thing?
People who have some common sense aren't CG's target demographic...
I have a pretty well modded Ult GL Rey. I have had played against a few Ult SLKR. The fact that Kylo does not take damage while in his ultimate stance is what kills GL Rey. She can get her ultimate even after Kylo starts his and Rey's ultimate will proc before Kylo is out of his stance. Now if you decide to not use the ultimate til later than you lose to Kylo's ultimate ripping everyone apart. If you were able to kill allies quicker this wouldn't be a problem but since the allies now have crit immunity (especially with one tank who gives advantage to a random ally for two turns as a unique) they take longer to kill and SLKR has more time to build up the ultimate that ends up going one right after the other do to the added time to kill.
I had rey do three whirlwinds on SLKR and he gains more health back than the whirlwind does damage on SLKR.
If you’re losing to SLKR on offense whilst using Rey then that’s completely on you. You should never lose on offense with Rey, take a look at your team or maybe stick on auto seeing as you’re clearly miss-using her kit
I have a pretty well modded Ult GL Rey. I have had played against a few Ult SLKR. The fact that Kylo does not take damage while in his ultimate stance is what kills GL Rey. She can get her ultimate even after Kylo starts his and Rey's ultimate will proc before Kylo is out of his stance. Now if you decide to not use the ultimate til later than you lose to Kylo's ultimate ripping everyone apart. If you were able to kill allies quicker this wouldn't be a problem but since the allies now have crit immunity (especially with one tank who gives advantage to a random ally for two turns as a unique) they take longer to kill and SLKR has more time to build up the ultimate that ends up going one right after the other do to the added time to kill.
I had rey do three whirlwinds on SLKR and he gains more health back than the whirlwind does damage on SLKR.
If you’re losing to SLKR on offense whilst using Rey then that’s completely on you. You should never lose on offense with Rey, take a look at your team or maybe stick on auto seeing as you’re clearly miss-using her kit
Nonsense. They've wound the dial up and didn't think about the unintended consequences. Because they're incompetent as we all know.
Replies
the damage reduction and crit-ing are 2 different things and not related in that way,
the way it is working is that Kylo crits and does X damage. Her special then reduces this to 1 damage.
Now people like me who went for Rey have a character who is less capable in PVE, and he's just as good as her in PVP. This buff was completely unnecessary and like taking a sledgehammer to fix a minor GAS counter. JKR still beats Rey...should we expect a buff for that?
Fixed implies something is broken. The first time he does it, if Rey is running GK (which is the common team), everyone gets crit immunity. Unless you have some other way to dispel it, you either need to spend an ultimate turn clearing buffs, or just AOE without crits.
Unless they change HSTR reward payouts, it's definitely consequential. There's a major difference between rank 1-10 and rank 11 rewards. Getting a solo with multiple teams is incredibly unlikely (you'd have to get into each phase before anyone posts any damage to that phase, and then solo with that team fast enough to get into the next phase in the same situation). If your guild has 10 SLKRs soloing, then you're locked out of top 10 rewards without him.
This is a huge issue. Because I chose Rey over Kylo, I will soon be locked out of useful rewards from the STR. That's kind of a problem, since that's the biggest source of the g12+ gear.
I didn't say it did. just wanted to make sure they knew what was going on according to what they were saying.
They are aware, and there are discussions. Thats all i got to share right now.
Yup....whoever thought GL’s would be good for the game must have never played SWGOH.
Not in a game. In a game it could mean that it is an unexpected interaction. But that’s also only one comp. There are others where this happens. There are videos on it.
Ye,never, a crit is a crit is not a bug the the ability is as intended...
because reasons?
You can’t tell me with a straight face that Ultimate Infinite Loop Kylo along with hit hard enough to circumvent procting damage immunity on Rey’s teammates, one of the most valuable pieces of her kit, is balanced with Rey.
Please, honestly.
I can tell you I will need you to reword that because I have no clue what you are saying. From what I can gather you are trying to extrapolate something from what I said in reply to another post, to make some point that I was not trying to discuss.....
I had rey do three whirlwinds on SLKR and he gains more health back than the whirlwind does damage on SLKR.
she cant be used in gr missions
she cant be used in jedi missions
she cant be used in special missions
one of the important characters is already used for rjt (hero finn) who guarantees 16/16 with rtj
so unless something magical happens in p4 i dont see her value in geo tb so far
overall hsr top10 is still the most important gearincome and thats kylos spot
Well what should be a bug is the infinite loop. If you want it around, then go for it. I don’t care as it doesn’t affect me rn, so I couldn’t care less. Do what you want.
Just that it won't work on people who still have some common sense. A big whale in my arena has just quit the game for good. This was the final straw for many people. But CG should not only care about the whales but rather think about the larger group of "average" p(l)ayers. Theory crafting and finding better solutions than a boring mirror match are what makes the game fun. If there's no more fun, why get hyped for the next big thing?
People who have some common sense aren't CG's target demographic...
If you’re losing to SLKR on offense whilst using Rey then that’s completely on you. You should never lose on offense with Rey, take a look at your team or maybe stick on auto seeing as you’re clearly miss-using her kit
Nonsense. They've wound the dial up and didn't think about the unintended consequences. Because they're incompetent as we all know.