Why are Jedi so weak

Prev13
Since reading about the Yoda event, I stopped farming anyone not a Jedi, and have grown my team as so.

My current A team

7* Lumi, 5 *Barris, 5* QGJ, 5* Yoda, and (depending on the match) 5* Dooku or 6* Sid

My issue is that now that I am rocking a mainly Jedi team, my team has dropped in the arena, and I STILL can't beat GW anymore.

Anyway, there are a LOT of toons that are set up to inflict MAJOR damage to my Jedi squad. Every hit is either stunning or ability blocking me. Is there ANY recourse to this? Currently, I use my Barris as leader for the amazing heal buffs at the start of each turn. But there again, when they are being stunned or ability blocked, I'm toast. Would putting QGJ as my leader be better than Barris?

There is a reason there aren't many Jedi teams. There are some real anti Jedi measures. While none of my Jedi have any special abilities against other toons. Not complaining, I'm just asking what I should/can do.

Any help is greatly appreciated!

Replies

  • Wazlinski
    359 posts Member
    edited February 2016
    Options
    .
  • Options
    Lumi and QGJ ain't weak
  • Options
    Lumi and QGJ ain't weak

    There isn't anything "weak" about Lumi. While QGJ hits hard, especially with his assist attack, he has less health than Dooku. And Yoda ain't much better... Sure they hit ok, but other than Lumi and especially Barris, their health is pitiful. That's at lvl70 with lvl8 gear...
  • Options
    aayla secura is great too.
  • Options
    Sorry, I guess I should of titled it better. Perhaps I should of asked why do they have such low health? - Why do so many toons have anti Jedi strengths?
  • Options
    The Jedi aren't necessarily weak but there are a ton of them. Some are in bad need of a rework and others are doing pretty well. The jedi also have more built in counters (maul, cad, Sid, etc.)

    Jedi aren't supposed to be "seeking" revenge lol, but as Obi wan said in the clone wars "Dooku doesn't share our sense of honor" so the sith are more troublesome for the Jedi.

    I just don't see a full Jedi team doing well currently. Then again, a full sith-ish team wouldn't either.
  • Options
    most of the jedi are underpowered and need reworked.
  • Options
    I too have crossed paths with very effective Jedi killers (I'm thinking of Cad Bane and Darth Maul, and Darth Sidious becomes very difficult to hit). Alas, I can offer no solution other than to try to select non-Jedi when you run across anti-Jedi specialists.
  • Options
    crimp47 wrote: »
    I too have crossed paths with very effective Jedi killers (I'm thinking of Cad Bane and Darth Maul, and Darth Sidious becomes very difficult to hit). Alas, I can offer no solution other than to try to select non-Jedi when you run across anti-Jedi specialists.

    My issue isn't really not hitting them. The issue I am having is more of them hitting and stunning or ability blocking me. I swear, sometimes I will go an entire match with Barris never getting to use a heal without being blocked or stunned again.
  • Options
    Jedi's are far from weak. Without Jedi you just can't get far into GW which is a large part of the game. Even in Arena, at least most of the top 10 players in my server use QGJ as leader.

    Actually Jedi is the strongest class (excluding the functional classes i.e. attacker/tank/healer/support) in this game. Just think about any team of 5 toons from the same class, Jedi team can beat all the others, even the Sith team.
  • Options
    Jedis are really strong. Yoda has best utility. QGJ has good speed. lumi has good heals and dps.
    An all jedi team is weak.
    An all sith team of Sid, maul, savage, dooku and vader is also weak.
    Have you guys seen an all sith team in teh arena top 100? yeah non existent.
  • Options
    crimp47 wrote: »
    I too have crossed paths with very effective Jedi killers (I'm thinking of Cad Bane and Darth Maul, and Darth Sidious becomes very difficult to hit). Alas, I can offer no solution other than to try to select non-Jedi when you run across anti-Jedi specialists.

    My issue isn't really not hitting them. The issue I am having is more of them hitting and stunning or ability blocking me. I swear, sometimes I will go an entire match with Barris never getting to use a heal without being blocked or stunned again.

    Barris just sucks ... no barris in top 20 pvp
  • Options
    Jedarkside wrote: »
    crimp47 wrote: »
    I too have crossed paths with very effective Jedi killers (I'm thinking of Cad Bane and Darth Maul, and Darth Sidious becomes very difficult to hit). Alas, I can offer no solution other than to try to select non-Jedi when you run across anti-Jedi specialists.

    My issue isn't really not hitting them. The issue I am having is more of them hitting and stunning or ability blocking me. I swear, sometimes I will go an entire match with Barris never getting to use a heal without being blocked or stunned again.

    Barris just sucks ... no barris in top 20 pvp

    But she is goddess in gw. But in arena, yeah I agree. If I see a barris lead, I target that guy
  • Options
    Barris sucks as a leader in arena. Youll get focused alot. Arena meta now is about speed.
    Once you face a QGJ lead/yoda/Anakin + 2 dps teams youll know what jedis are all about.. Theyl kill 1 or 2 of yours before you can even act.
  • Options
    Barris sucks as a leader in arena. Youll get focused alot. Arena meta now is about speed.
    Once you face a QGJ lead/yoda/Anakin + 2 dps teams youll know what jedis are all about.. Theyl kill 1 or 2 of yours before you can even act.

    I can already kill 1 before most attack using QGJ assist attack and I have all of those toons you mentioned. My QGJ is 1/2 way to 6*, Yoda is 5*, but I have just unlocked my Anakin. So he is 4* still sitting untouched. All my resources this week have been getting QGJ to lvl70. Anakin was my next plan. However, would he be viable as a 4* with my current Jedi team?

    Current setup is 7*Lumi, almost 6*Barris, 1/2 way to 6* QGJ, 5*Yoda, and 4*Anakin? It's hard for me to put a 4* in now... Would Anakin work as a 4* with this setup?

    Also, what about the leader? I should use QGJ in the arena, and Barris in the GW? I have been using Barris as my leader for the health buff. It seems he (QGJ) is really helped by the extra health he is awarded from having Barris as my lead. But would the speed buff make up for the loss in overall health, AND over 1000 health at the start of each turn? Is speed REALLY THAT valuable?
  • Options
    Oh yeah, and earlier, I had Yoda, Barris, and Lumi stunned. I had QGJ and Dooku not stunned. I did QGJ assist move, and Dooku didn't come to assist, which I take as QGJ called in one of the stunned toons to assist him. Has anyone else seen this or had this happen? Is that supposed to happen? It seems logical to me if 3 of 5 are stunned, and an assist move is called, the remaining unstunned character should jump in for the assist. Now is it just me who thinks it's crazy he called for the assist from a stunned squad mate?
  • Options
    Oh yeah, and earlier, I had Yoda, Barris, and Lumi stunned. I had QGJ and Dooku not stunned. I did QGJ assist move, and Dooku didn't come to assist, which I take as QGJ called in one of the stunned toons to assist him. Has anyone else seen this or had this happen? Is that supposed to happen? It seems logical to me if 3 of 5 are stunned, and an assist move is called, the remaining unstunned character should jump in for the assist. Now is it just me who thinks it's crazy he called for the assist from a stunned squad mate?

    Yeah that's supposed to happen. I guess it's the counter to the call assist attacks
  • Options
    I took first in arena this week with 7* QGJ, Lumi, Yoda, Sid, and 4* Old Ben. I'm always top 5 in Arena and thats running 4 Jedi.
  • Options
    Well the fact that Anakin was supposed to be the most powerful jedi ever, it is disappointing that he is so weak in this game.
  • Options
    Because of Order 66.
  • Options
    Well the fact that Anakin was supposed to be the most powerful jedi ever, it is disappointing that he is so weak in this game.

    Anakin and mace especially are seriously underrepresented in the game sadly. I love mace Windu. But not the Galaxy of heroes Windu. Even with the small
    Buff they gave him, it's still nothing like he's mean to be.
  • Options
    Note to all, arena is only one part of the game, Jedi are awesome and required in every other area (except DS of course)
    "I find your lack of faith disturbing" - Darth Vader
  • Options
    Because the devs decided jedi/sith aren't the main reason fans like the star wars series. Seriously
  • Options
    @Speaker4thedead remove your Barris, use qgj as leader and use both sid and dooku and you'll do just fine. Barris is not good for pvp anyway.
  • Options
    My Jedis wreck shop! And the team isn't completed yet! Right now I'm running
    7* QGJ as lead/7* lumi/7*jc/6*Ahsoka/7* Darth Sid
    And I'm always top. (Although I ranked down sometimes because they target my Ahsoka)

    I have 6 star 20/100 anakin but waiting on a few purple mats to bring him out. I also have 5 star Yoda But waiting on the Yoda event again to get 7*. I plan on replacing sid and Ahsoka for anakin and Yoda.
  • JohnnySteelAlpha
    2794 posts Member
    edited February 2016
    Options
    You just need to star your Jedi - also your team comp is not optimized. You need to get Jinn to 7* and Yoda as well for that boost in health that makes them arena viable. Ideally you'd have Anakin in there as well, not Barriss, so that you have some sort of theme. Either be fast and high damage or be slower and tank / heal. That current setup doesn't have enough power / speed to kill stuff, but at those star levels and with those characters you can't tank very well and take damage either. Essentially your growing squad at this point has not primary strength - which is expected as it's in development. You'd want QGJ as your leader - because right now you have a slower / lower health Jedi team with Barriss as your lead, but still trying to use Yoda / Jinn. Look to build a team that has a clear strength and make QGJ your leader. That will make Lumi fast and Yoda really fast - and of course QGJ will then be able to attack / lead with that assist. If you had Anakin now you have 3 toons at light speed. Old Ben is also a great Jedi. Aayla and Kit are solid too, but not top top tier. I realize they are chrome only, but they are Jedi and good ones if they ever come available.

    I've definitely seen all Jedi teams take #1 in arena and they are deadly: QGJ leader, Lumi, Anakin, Yoda, and Old Ben is a very capable team comp.

    I think if everyone had all the Jedi - if the best ones were easily available - this type of question wouldn't really come up. Jedi in this game as a group are very good and have the best depth and options.
  • LukeSkywalker420
    460 posts Member
    edited February 2016
    Options
    You dont need two healers in Arena replace Barris with a damage dealer can use Sid for now and then get Poe so you can taunt and protect the QGJ and Yoda while they do their damage. (Or Stormtrooper Han) and put QGJ as leader for Arena.
  • Options
    Barris sucks as a leader in arena. Youll get focused alot. Arena meta now is about speed.
    Once you face a QGJ lead/yoda/Anakin + 2 dps teams youll know what jedis are all about.. Theyl kill 1 or 2 of yours before you can even act.

    I can already kill 1 before most attack using QGJ assist attack and I have all of those toons you mentioned. My QGJ is 1/2 way to 6*, Yoda is 5*, but I have just unlocked my Anakin. So he is 4* still sitting untouched. All my resources this week have been getting QGJ to lvl70. Anakin was my next plan. However, would he be viable as a 4* with my current Jedi team?

    Current setup is 7*Lumi, almost 6*Barris, 1/2 way to 6* QGJ, 5*Yoda, and 4*Anakin? It's hard for me to put a 4* in now... Would Anakin work as a 4* with this setup?

    Also, what about the leader? I should use QGJ in the arena, and Barris in the GW? I have been using Barris as my leader for the health buff. It seems he (QGJ) is really helped by the extra health he is awarded from having Barris as my lead. But would the speed buff make up for the loss in overall health, AND over 1000 health at the start of each turn? Is speed REALLY THAT valuable?

    Yes speed is THAT valuable in teh arena. To put it in context, some people (including myslef) use QGJs leader ability even if hes the ONLY Jedi in the team. The goal is to kill 1 or 2 of his toons before he can act, then you seal your victory.

    People also seldom use healers as theres no point. If you have a team of DPS/DPS/DPS/Suport/healer, and I kill your 2 DPS before your turn, theres a very slim chance you ca recover having only a dps/dupport and healer.

    Bariss is really good in the GW though as a 3rd backup healer or against a team w/ sid and kylo anti heals.
  • Options
    Well the fact that Anakin was supposed to be the most powerful jedi ever, it is disappointing that he is so weak in this game.

    Anakin is very strong in the right team. Top players are already using him.
    1st, you have to use him w/ QGJ, so hes very fast.
    2nd most top teams carry a full DPS 1st turn teams, so usually they will take out 1 or 2 of your guys if RNG is against you. But w/ anakin around hell take an extra turn and retaliate w/ higher damage and kill his toons as well.
    3rd hes tanky so he wont be focused 1st.
    4th he can easily give offense up if timing is right.

    Speed is key in this current meta, and hes very fast.
  • Options
    Right now I'm running 5* Yoda Lead/ 7* Lum/ 7*JC/ 7* Eeth Koth and 7* Poggle. This works well against the Sid/Duku/Phasma/Daka/Kylo teams that have spread like wild fire over my server. I rarely get hit with healing immunity, plus all extra resist make my team go fairly fast for the first couple round, which are the only one that really matter. The only reason why this team works is because Yoda is a direct counter with stacking both his leader tenacity up and battle meditations. Oh and Poggle is big key, no way a F2P full Jedi team can do well on squad area... I'm doing well on offense in the squad arena but Jedi are horrible on defense. I can get down to top 50, probably further but i refuse to spend shards on squad arena. The problem is I can go from top 50 to over 200 in one day because defense is so terrible. Jedi Master Ailan is a P2P player who has a popular youtube channel with daily SWGOH videos. He is in top 5 in his server and shows in some of his recent videos that Jedi Squad doesn't work for P2P either, once again because the defense is so bad. The only way i see this improving is by making each Jedi have some sort of anti-sith passive's and fixing all the broken/useless Jedi.

    Here's some key F2P Jedi character changes that are crucial and easy to fix:

    - Ashoka needs way more speed, she is flat out useless. Her leader ability is also trash, it might be viable if EVERYONE got turn meter on evade, similar to Duku offence up.

    - Mace Windu needs a better package (See character feedback on him, there is a lot he is still falling short with). His IA mechanics don't work either. When he finally does expose and doesn't get resisted he often doesn't even attack that character. He might be slightly usable if this got fix but even then, in no way is he a strong character.

    - Ploo Koon is another badly broken character, **** all damage and has offence down move with almost no potency. Explain that one lol.

    - Barris's passive doesn't work, I've never once seen her passive remove a neg status effect. She could also definitely use more damage, i'm sorry but that noodle she hits with just doesn't cut it. The ONLY real role she plays in is leader in GW, not very viable when a character has only one use.

    - Jedi Knight Gardian is still way too slow and with no taunt does no ware near enough damage. Another useless Jedi


    Long story short, EA has a fair amount of changes to make before making Jedi a serious force to be reckon with in Squad Arena. Simply putting Yoda in the game does not make up for all the broken and lack luster
    F2P Jedi characters. The really disappointing part is I spend all my time, efforts and in-game currency towards developing Jedi because to me Jedi is what Star Wars is all about. Only to find out that as F2P they can't seriously compete in Squad Arena. Having said all that I will still continue to work on my Jedi Roster primary in hopes that all the character flaws get fixed in the future.

    Thanks if you took the time to read this rant lol.

    Cheers!
    ☮ Consular ☮
Sign In or Register to comment.