Territory War Matchmaker

Replies

  • Please fix matchmaking sometimes we win, sometimes we lose. When we lose it always because matchmaking aka sandbagging. When we win it's always because we are the better guild and have better teams.

    Clearly matchmaking is broken because we have developed our rosters a lot and deserve to always win.

    Who's with me?
  • This system is so incredibly broken. Sandbagging is so common this node should be called Star Wars Galaxy Of Sandbagging.
    o7nd5kan9ezg.jpg
    Lørd' Ąngęłùs
    "Well begun is half done."
  • v5u3cmcui7kg.jpeg


    We always get these kind of matchups. Can’t remember the last time we had a decent matchup.
  • Ally
    23 posts Member
    edited January 14
    Date of TW: 14/01/19
    Your Guild’s GP: 132m
    Opposing team’s GP:: 171m
    # of my guild members who joined: 42
    # of opposing guild members who joined:30

    DMs 5 Vs 12
    Darth Revans 9 Vs 28
    JKRs 28 vs 39

    We dont have much chance.
    Post edited by Ally on
  • 4 territory wars in a row against guilds with only 46/48 members joining. No chance.

    This is disgusting and CG as usual ignoring the player base.
  • 6 TW with 35 to 40 players joining in my guild. Los them all, your issues are not related to having a couple more people then the other guild. Your issue is the same as my guild. Just not that good at pvp, way too much bad GP, not enough high end meta GP.

    The gap between each guilds top end meta GP is what makes a TW a mismatch.
  • Gonzolo
    53 posts Member
    edited January 27
    Date of TW: 12/28/19
    Your Guild’s GP: 208m
    Opposing team’s GP: 225m
    # of my guild members who joined: 46
    # of opposing guild members who joined: 39
    We had no chance here, they full cleared us in about 4 hours

    Date of TW: 1/13/20
    Your Guild’s GP: 213m
    Opposing team’s GP: 238m
    # of my guild members who joined: 49
    # of opposing guild members who joined: 43
    Another big loss

    Date of TW: 1/24/20
    Your guilds GP: 216m
    Opposing teams GP: 240m
    # of my guild members who joined:48
    # of opposing guild who joined: 43

    It seems like an easy fix on sandbagging should be that the first step of matchmaking compare number of people signed up before any further data is considered. This is three of last five where we have had an egregious mismatch.
    Post edited by Gonzolo on
  • Normal ?!
    cqebegnqeqnd.jpg
  • I figure it like this. The matchup system is there to give whale guilds warm fuzzies so they keep spending. Which keeps the game free for the rest of us. Works for me, cheers mates thanks for paying for the drinks!

  • DarthDarthDarth
    26 posts Member
    edited February 12
    Date of TW: 10 February 2020
    Your Guild’s GP: 237,004,794
    Opposing team’s GP: 268,456,070
    # of my guild members who joined: 50
    # of opposing guild members who joined: 44

    Position 3 hours into the TW:
    Screenshot_20200211-080649.jpg?width=1068&height=534

    twCompare.png


    Not going to complain about the matchup, these guys have played according to the rules, but it does suck the fun out of the game to have such a crazy uneven matchup.
    Post edited by DarthDarthDarth on
  • Fix this stupid **** mode. And how can we beat similar teams so easy on grand arena. Then in TW flop and spend 5 teams and still not win. Don’t give me the mod excuse ****. Something is up because we all fail. I wish I could work for y’all. Get paid to fail at life.
  • Fix this stupid **** mode. And how can we beat similar teams so easy on grand arena. Then in TW flop and spend 5 teams and still not win. Don’t give me the mod excuse ****. Something is up because we all fail. I wish I could work for y’all. Get paid to fail at life.

    You answered your own complaint in the post lol. Mods are why you fail
    Looking for a new guild? Come check out the Underworld Alliance on Discord:https://discord.gg/wvrYb4Q
  • If you guys think a 30 million g.p. difference is fair... you must be smoking some good crack. It was fair 7 months ago... now it is back to garbage. You guys need to stop tinkering with things and leave unbroken things where they are. Every time things seem to be fair you guys make a mistake and every time you do... you say we are all lying or full of it. If you're patrons are complaining... good companies listen. When the entire community is crying about something... perhaps it means you have an issue. I work in customer service.... you can't ignore facts... if you do... you are the problem!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • cbutlodjfprh.jpg
    See!!!!!
  • Svephen
    10 posts Member
    I've previously reported a guild on matchmaking but coming on here I see that although its on the report interface we shouldn't actually be using that for it. So here I am.

    Date of TW: 09/04/2020
    Your Guild’s GP: 160m https://swgoh.gg/g/46380/separatist-legion/
    Opposing team’s GP: 178m https://swgoh.gg/g/3487/projectx/
    # of my guild members who joined: 46/49
    # of opposing guild members who joined: [unknown]
  • Svephen wrote: »
    I've previously reported a guild on matchmaking but coming on here I see that although its on the report interface we shouldn't actually be using that for it. So here I am.

    Date of TW: 09/04/2020
    Your Guild’s GP: 160m https://swgoh.gg/g/46380/separatist-legion/
    Opposing team’s GP: 178m https://swgoh.gg/g/3487/projectx/
    # of my guild members who joined: 46/49
    # of opposing guild members who joined: [unknown]
    It’s not unknown how many of them joined. It’s double the number of defence slots you have to fill per zone (or one less than that).


  • Svephen wrote: »
    I've previously reported a guild on matchmaking but coming on here I see that although its on the report interface we shouldn't actually be using that for it. So here I am.

    Date of TW: 09/04/2020
    Your Guild’s GP: 160m https://swgoh.gg/g/46380/separatist-legion/
    Opposing team’s GP: 178m https://swgoh.gg/g/3487/projectx/
    # of my guild members who joined: 46/49
    # of opposing guild members who joined: [unknown]
    It’s not unknown how many of them joined. It’s double the number of defence slots you have to fill per zone (or one less than that).


    Thanks for the clarification!
  • The result of the match for further context.
  • Guys, TW is another fund raiser. You are seeing mismatched matches to anger you into spending to build better teams. Join, deploy, walk away. Claim rewards, which win or lose are not that different. It's not going to change. I get it, it sux losing. I tell my guys just what I said here. It's daycare for whales. Setup matches they can't lose. Meh.. They spend so you don't have to. Why sweat it?

    Be safe, be healthy, cya in the trenches :)

  • XiVordu
    2 posts Member
    edited April 11
    First time I report Matchmaking here but it's a long time I should have reported it...
    This is time to make changes because there's no fun for our members to play anymore...

    Date of TW: 09/04/2020
    Your Guild’s GP: 270m https://swgoh.gg/g/40624/galaxie-orion/
    Opposing team’s GP: 290m https://swgoh.gg/g/42/chewbakwa/
    # of my guild members who joined: 50/50
    # of opposing guild members who joined: 46/50

    And we can whale as harder as we could, if we systematically match like that, we can't have fun anymore in TW... And this is frequently the case. There is a lot of guilds who join the tw with 45/46 members or less just to have the advantage. And those matches are just impossible.
    Please, change those mismatches.
    I'll do other reports when I see mismatches. And I will do another quite quickly because it often happens...
  • XiVordu wrote: »
    First time I report Matchmaking here but it's a long time I should have reported it...
    This is time to make changes because there's no fun for our members to play anymore...

    Date of TW: 09/04/2020
    Your Guild’s GP: 270m https://swgoh.gg/g/40624/galaxie-orion/
    Opposing team’s GP: 290m https://swgoh.gg/g/42/chewbakwa/
    # of my guild members who joined: 50/50
    # of opposing guild members who joined: 46/50

    And we can whale as harder as we could, if we systematically match like that, we can't have fun anymore in TW... And this is frequently the case. There is a lot of guilds who join the tw with 45/46 members or less just to have the advantage. And those matches are just impossible.
    Please, change those mismatches.
    I'll do other reports when I see mismatches. And I will do another quite quickly because it often happens...
    As has been stated time and again, there are a lot of guilds who make TW optional, so only 45/46 signup.

    How do you know this guild deliberately left 4/5 people out?
  • Please fix matchmaking sometimes we win, sometimes we lose. When we lose it always because matchmaking aka sandbagging. When we win it's always because we are the better guild and have better teams.

    Clearly matchmaking is broken because we have developed our rosters a lot and deserve to always win.

    Who's with me?

    The Term sand bagging is so widely used. If people dont wish to participate? or cannot?
    We have 50 in our guild but some cannot make it due to commitments.
    It is what it is. No one is told you cant join TW
    Everyone is given the opportunity.
    If you dont win or cant win, suck it up, its the nature of the beast.
    Its rare that any guild does actually sand bag anything
  • Me again.

    Date of TW: 13/04/2020
    Your Guild’s GP: 167m (first time we got 50/50 to join - woo!) https://swgoh.gg/g/46380/separatist-legion/
    Opposing team’s GP: 210m https://swgoh.gg/g/9588/platoon/
    # of my guild members who joined: 50
    # of opposing guild members who joined: 38
  • 9 times out of 10, the problem is that 200M GP with 50 players is not the same as 200M GP with 42 players, but the matchmaking engine thinks it is. I don't see why it is so hard to match up guilds with another guild that is the same number of participants (or +/- 1.) Sandbagging would stop overnight.
  • rokota
    138 posts Member
    After introducing the GL the matchmaking is even more broken than before.

    Our actual opponent has galactic legends and 7 GAS compared to our one GAS. We do not even have a Wat Tambor, so this battle is over before it started.

    If this is CGs version of a sandbox mode, than it is not a very well designed one ;)
  • Date of TW: 26th April 2020

    You Guild's GP: 169m, 50/50 joined
    https://swgoh.gg/g/46380/separatist-legion/

    Opponent Guild's GP: 217m, 38/50 based on 19 slots available in TW.
    https://swgoh.gg/g/287/olympus/

    As a result of being repeatedly mismatched due to low participation their end (in which we are being punished for, not them) it is no longer a requirement in my guild to join TW, since there's plenty of incentive to be matched to guilds lower than oneself.

    t3lovug20re7.jpeg
  • 2 years later and nothing is getting done - for something that is a huge element of the game you think there would be a little bit of attention or acknowledgement
  • Whats even the point of fighting this???
    This is really a joke.
    My guild Husaria Polska. Everyone joined 226mln GP. But what's a gp when there are
    20 more GSsys, almost everything in red, 4Gls when we have none.
    There really should be some boundaries in the matchmaker, when currently there seems to not be.
    @CG_SBCrumb

    4v9ucvrcu7nc.png

  • Date of TW April 29 2020

    Our gild 268kk power 50 players
    Opponents 305kk power 44?? Players
    Teams per territory 22

    Second time we found this guild, second time it's impossible for us to win
    I'm very tired for this matchmaking
    u9g5a975i77a.jpg
    37ecgv504pjh.jpg

  • Sarbitar
    230 posts Member
    So why the hell put up a thread and then do not provide any info about this?

    We've got another **** matchup - I doubt it's really funny for both guilds.
Sign In or Register to comment.